Q&A · 1:31:36-1:34:14

F3 battlecruisers and the cancelled American capital ships

The answer favours an F3-based alternative for Britain and considers how the cancelled American ships could have changed fleet development.

Question

Which practical unbuilt warship designs are especially interesting?

Short answer

The preferred British example is F3 with 15-inch/50 guns; the cancelled 1920 South Dakotas and Lexington battlecruisers are also considered consequential alternatives.

Notes

The F3 design with a 15-inch/50 gun is the preferred British example of an interesting unbuilt ship. A hypothetical choice of F3s in place of Nelson and Rodney is judged better suited to the navy's developing task-force approach. The argument also imagines later ships and refits using that gun, including King George V-class battleships with nine 15-inch/50 weapons. A 15-inch/45 is another possibility for the refits, depending on the choice made at the time. This is explicitly a judgment influenced by hindsight. For the United States, completing the 1920 South Dakota class and Lexington battlecruisers is expected to produce a different fleet for the Second World War. The Dakotas receive particular weight in the assessment, although no detailed American war scenario is developed.