Q&A ยท 1:15:51-1:16:51

Choosing capital-ship guns after the treaty system breaks

Prestige and ammunition commonality point toward different guns in the fictional fleet scenario.

Question

Would Britain choose 16-inch guns for prestige in the Defence counterfactual?

Short answer

That is one preference, while 14-inch commonality offers a logistical reason to choose otherwise.

Notes

With treaty constraints removed by the Defence substitution, the KGV design is imagined with either more 14-inch weapons or a heavier battery of 16-inch guns. A participant asks whether prestige would favor the larger caliber. Alex distinguishes his personal inclination toward larger guns from the choice a historical planner such as Henderson might make. The competing 14-inch argument is common ammunition logistics with the new cruiser fleet.