Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 3:48:00-3:50:43

A B-17 crashing into a Japanese carrier at Midway

A freak B-17 crash could sink or disable a Japanese carrier, but its largest effect might be changing whether the fleet presses on to the historical battle.

Aircraft CarriersAlternate HistoryBattle Of MidwayDamage ControlImperial Japanese Navy
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

What changes if a B-17 hit by flak crashes into a Japanese carrier at Midway?

Short answer

The carrier could be lost, and an early Japanese withdrawal in response might prevent the historical carrier battle from unfolding at all.

Notes

Japanese carriers emphasized air-group capacity more than the ability to absorb an impact of this scale, leaving any of the Midway force in serious danger from a crashing heavy bomber. The older or lighter carriers were especially vulnerable, but the operational decision that follows matters more. If the loss warns the Japanese that strong American forces are present and prompts withdrawal, the carrier fleet may survive for a different battle and the familiar Midway sequence never occurs.