Video
Top 5 Inventions that came too Early...
Study Top 5 Inventions that came too Early..., a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 7 Jan 2023, with 13 time notes. Topics include Amphibious Warfare, Danish Navy, Defence Procurement.
Time notes
- 1:30Ramjets before the materials could support themChapter
The first case study uses Rene Lorin's 1913 ramjet idea to show how a promising invention can wait on metallurgy and materials science.
- 7:16Nunn-McCurdy cost controls meet procurement politicsChapter
A procurement-law section explains why sensible cost-growth triggers still collide with contractors, lobbyists, alternatives, and management incentives.
- 12:01Future Combat Systems trades a concrete chassis plan for vaguer modernizationNotable Point
The U.S. Army's Future Combat Systems case contrasts a concrete common-chassis proposal with a broader modernization program whose vagueness avoids firm promises.
- 14:00Good engineering schedules leave time to test the machinery firstNotable Point
A shipyard manager's scheduling rule and prewar aircraft practice illustrate why platforms should not be promised before their core machinery works.
- 17:10EFV cancellation leaves the Marines balancing old and new assault vehiclesChapter
The EFV-to-ACV replacement story sets a costly new amphibious vehicle against a much larger fleet of aging AAV7s and a constrained Marine Corps budget.
- 21:27Christmas-tree programs recruit allies but can threaten rival budgetsNotable Point
The EFV becomes a lesson in how adding requirements builds a program's political coalition until its scale begins to endanger other priorities.
- 24:35EFV cancellation assumes safer beaches or decisive long-range firesNotable Point
The rationale for dispensing with a long-range amphibious vehicle rests on unopposed landings or other services clearing coastal missile threats first.
- 25:35Zumwalt and railguns show the power-supply problemNotable Point
The Zumwalt discussion separates the destroyer from its immature railgun and asks whether only a nuclear surface combatant could sustain the weapon's electrical demand.
- 27:44Zumwalt design overreach reaches the peripheral VLS arrangementNotable Point
A critique of Zumwalt's peripheral launch cells shows how insisting that every feature be novel can turn an interesting destroyer into a perceived failure.
- 30:46Project Excalibur needs materials able to survive its own nuclear blastChapter
The nuclear-pumped laser at the heart of Project Excalibur illustrates the gap between a dramatic missile-defense concept and materials capable of making it work.
- 33:51Brilliant Pebbles turns missile defence into an orbital interceptor networkNotable Point
Autonomous tungsten interceptors and their sensor network make Brilliant Pebbles the SDI proposal presented as closest to conventional deployment.
- 36:30LCS failure does not prove modular warships cannot workChapter
The closing case separates Littoral Combat Ship execution from modular-warship theory and points to Denmark's older StanFlex system as a counterexample.
- 38:12StanFlex offers a baseline for a Danish-American frigateNotable Point
A hypothetical U.S.-Danish development path uses StanFlex interfaces and Danish contract discipline to imagine a more useful American frigate.