Video

Top 5 Inventions that came too Early...

Study Top 5 Inventions that came too Early..., a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 7 Jan 2023, with 13 time notes. Topics include Amphibious Warfare, Danish Navy, Defence Procurement.

Date
Runtime42:51
Guide points13 time notes

Time notes

  1. 1:30
    Ramjets before the materials could support them

    The first case study uses Rene Lorin's 1913 ramjet idea to show how a promising invention can wait on metallurgy and materials science.

    Chapter
  2. 7:16
    Nunn-McCurdy cost controls meet procurement politics

    A procurement-law section explains why sensible cost-growth triggers still collide with contractors, lobbyists, alternatives, and management incentives.

    Chapter
  3. 12:01
    Future Combat Systems trades a concrete chassis plan for vaguer modernization

    The U.S. Army's Future Combat Systems case contrasts a concrete common-chassis proposal with a broader modernization program whose vagueness avoids firm promises.

    Notable Point
  4. 14:00
    Good engineering schedules leave time to test the machinery first

    A shipyard manager's scheduling rule and prewar aircraft practice illustrate why platforms should not be promised before their core machinery works.

    Notable Point
  5. 17:10
    EFV cancellation leaves the Marines balancing old and new assault vehicles

    The EFV-to-ACV replacement story sets a costly new amphibious vehicle against a much larger fleet of aging AAV7s and a constrained Marine Corps budget.

    Chapter
  6. 21:27
    Christmas-tree programs recruit allies but can threaten rival budgets

    The EFV becomes a lesson in how adding requirements builds a program's political coalition until its scale begins to endanger other priorities.

    Notable Point
  7. 24:35
    EFV cancellation assumes safer beaches or decisive long-range fires

    The rationale for dispensing with a long-range amphibious vehicle rests on unopposed landings or other services clearing coastal missile threats first.

    Notable Point
  8. 25:35
    Zumwalt and railguns show the power-supply problem

    The Zumwalt discussion separates the destroyer from its immature railgun and asks whether only a nuclear surface combatant could sustain the weapon's electrical demand.

    Notable Point
  9. 27:44
    Zumwalt design overreach reaches the peripheral VLS arrangement

    A critique of Zumwalt's peripheral launch cells shows how insisting that every feature be novel can turn an interesting destroyer into a perceived failure.

    Notable Point
  10. 30:46
    Project Excalibur needs materials able to survive its own nuclear blast

    The nuclear-pumped laser at the heart of Project Excalibur illustrates the gap between a dramatic missile-defense concept and materials capable of making it work.

    Chapter
  11. 33:51
    Brilliant Pebbles turns missile defence into an orbital interceptor network

    Autonomous tungsten interceptors and their sensor network make Brilliant Pebbles the SDI proposal presented as closest to conventional deployment.

    Notable Point
  12. 36:30
    LCS failure does not prove modular warships cannot work

    The closing case separates Littoral Combat Ship execution from modular-warship theory and points to Denmark's older StanFlex system as a counterexample.

    Chapter
  13. 38:12
    StanFlex offers a baseline for a Danish-American frigate

    A hypothetical U.S.-Danish development path uses StanFlex interfaces and Danish contract discipline to imagine a more useful American frigate.

    Notable Point