Video
Shipbuilding trends of the 1880s-1950s: Long Patrol Part 10/11 Why the Battleship Fizzled Out
Study Shipbuilding trends of the 1880s-1950s: Long Patrol Part 10/11 Why the Battleship Fizzled Out, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 12 Sept 2021, with 13 time notes. Topics include Aircraft Carriers, Battleships, Cold War.
Time notes
- 0:13Why battleships fizzled outChapter
Battleships declined after 1945 because navies lost a compelling reason to buy them, rather than because their combat power suddenly vanished.
- 2:40A battleship built to meet another battleshipNotable Point
Battleship construction followed the perceived need to defeat an opposing battle line, even when aircraft had shown their striking power.
- 4:07Why the carrier was the more adaptable investmentChapter
A carrier can change missions with its air group, project power farther, and contribute to layered air defence.
- 5:06Postwar fleets lacked a battleship threat to answerNotable Point
With few opposing battleships left after 1945, cruisers and carriers could address most surface-raider problems more economically.
- 7:09Unnecessary is not the same as obsoleteChapter
The Royal Navy kept Vanguard as an insurance policy while expecting carriers and new destroyer technology to meet future needs.
- 8:43Fast submarines still had to find the convoyNotable Point
Very fast submarines did not make convoy escorts pointless because the attacker still had to approach the formation those escorts protected.
- 9:08Escalation constrained tactical nuclear weaponsNotable Point
Nuclear torpedoes looked formidable, but fear that any nuclear use could trigger wider escalation limited their practical attraction.
- 9:57Deterrence changed what major weapons were forNotable Point
Britain's heavy bombers illustrate how a useful weapon can lose its procurement rationale when another system assumes its defining mission.
- 11:26Carrier missions outlasted the battleship missionChapter
A carrier could be justified for land attack and fleet air defence even without an opposing carrier, unlike a battleship built around capital-ship combat.
- 12:38Inherited cruisers and Tiger-class test bedsNotable Point
Large inherited cruiser fleets reduced pressure for immediate replacement while the Tiger class tested technologies for the Royal Navy's next generation.
- 14:12Cruisers sustained global naval presenceNotable Point
A navy expected to appear around the world still needed cruisers because they performed presence and deployment duties more naturally than battleships.
- 14:44The destroyer as a versatile postwar combatantNotable Point
The Daring class shows why a large destroyer could support carrier escort, anti-submarine warfare, cruiser-like duties, and naval gunfire.
- 16:10The carrier replaced the battleship as the capital shipChapter
Carriers displaced battleships because their wider mission set gave them a continuing strategic purpose.