Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:34:34-2:35:31

The Zimmermann Telegram fit a wider pattern of German strategic incoherence

Germany simultaneously relied on American access for critical supplies and provoked the United States through submarine operations and the Zimmermann proposal.

German EmpireUnited StatesUnrestricted Submarine WarfareWorld War IZimmermann Telegram
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Was the Zimmermann Telegram so self-defeating that it was probably a British conspiracy?

Short answer

No; it fits a genuine pattern of contradictory German decisions that alienated the United States.

Notes

The Zimmermann Telegram need not have been a British fabrication simply because it was strategically foolish. Germany also depended on American access for low-volume but important war-industry supplies. German submarines were meanwhile operating near American waters and attacking merchant shipping in ways that embarrassed the United States. A government can pursue policies that undermine one another without requiring a hidden conspiracy.