Q&A ยท 1:42:19-1:42:33

Would a fleet sortie improve the air battle?

Kimmel would more likely sortie to find and attack the Japanese carriers than simply move the fleet offshore to support an air melee over Hawaii.

Question

If Kimmel put the fleet to sea, would an air battle over Hawaii produce a better outcome?

Short answer

Possibly, but Kimmel would more likely use the sortie to pursue the Japanese carriers than to keep the fleet near Hawaii for a local air melee.

Notes

A viewer asks whether putting the fleet to sea could have improved the air battle over Hawaii. Kimmel probably would not sortie merely to stage an air melee close to Pearl Harbor. His more likely purpose would be to seek and attack the Japanese carriers. Moving ships offshore and conducting an offensive search create different risks, objectives, and demands for reconnaissance.