Q&A ยท 3:58:29-4:00:28

Why the German 1934 type was a poor destroyer

The comparison with Tribal-class philosophy shows how one armament decision can defeat an otherwise promising destroyer concept.

Question

What were the worst destroyers built for their time?

Short answer

The German 1934 type receives the criticism because its light-cruiser-sized guns undermined the rate of fire, fire control, and maneuvering performance needed in the destroyer role.

Notes

The German design sought to cover a light-cruiser role, but its larger guns fired more slowly and became harder to control while the ship maneuvered violently. More numerous destroyer-caliber weapons, as used in the British Tribal concept, would have produced a far more dangerous opponent. The harsh assessment rests on Germany already having the experience to avoid this mismatch between weapon and mission.