Tribal-class destroyers versus Fletchers

Who wins between a flotilla of Tribal-class destroyers and a flotilla of Fletchers?

Probably the Tribals at close range, provided they dodge the Fletchers' torpedoes and exploit their heavier volume of gunfire.

The Tribals have the edge if they evade the initial torpedo threat and close to gun range. Their twin 4.7-inch mountings produce a formidable volume of fire, and the class was conceived to defeat enemy destroyers. The Fletchers remain dangerous because their torpedo battery and broader fleet role create a close, violent contest.