Would enlarged Town-class cruisers have lasted longer, and were postwar reserve decisions caused by manpower shortages?
Short answerTheir larger hulls offered useful modernization space, while the immediate personnel problem was demobilization and assignment rather than a simple absence of sailors.
NotesThe proposed larger Edinburgh-style cruiser could trade an after turret for a large helicopter hangar or missile installation while retaining substantial forward gun power. The panel then explains why the Royal Navy often preferred Town-class ships as modernization candidates. Their size offered more removable weight and internal margin than smaller cruisers. Postwar reserve decisions should not be reduced to a lack of people: the service was sorting conscripts, short-service commissions, volunteers, and new national-service rules, so personnel administration shaped which ships could be kept ready.