Q&A · 1:23:59-1:24:19

Why the torpedo-battleship concept did not take hold

Battleship-sized torpedo armament looked attractive in theory but lost out to the much greater reach of heavy guns.

Question

What was the torpedo-battleship concept before the First World War?

Short answer

Navies explored it, but gun range greatly exceeded torpedo range, making the concept impractical for capital-ship combat.

Notes

Several navies considered the torpedo-battleship idea, and Beatty became especially associated with it after the First World War. The concept seemed to offer answers to several capital-ship problems. Its central weakness was tactical range: torpedoes could not reach targets at the distances where a battleship's main battery could fight. That mismatch prevented the idea from delivering what its advocates expected.