Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 56:21-59:25

Why Tillman battleships would not win an Anglo-American building race

A strategy of forcing rivals to match giant American battleships fails if Britain answers with fast global cruisers and concentrated heavy units.

G3 Class BattlecruisersGlobal BasingN3 Class BattleshipsNaval Arms RaceRoyal NavyTillman Maximum Battleship DesignsUS Navy
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Could enormous Tillman battleships price Britain out of naval competition?

Short answer

Probably not; Britain could build asymmetrically around fast G3s, heavy N3s, and global bases instead of matching Tillmans ship for ship.

Notes

Equivalent capital ships cost more in the United States than in Britain's mature and geographically concentrated shipbuilding system, weakening the assumption that America could simply outspend every response. The Tillman concept also assumed that rival navies would answer giant battleships with identical ships. Britain could refuse that contest by using fast G3-type ships as a global reaction force operating through its worldwide bases. N3-type heavy units could threaten dispersed Tillmans, forcing the United States either to concentrate and leave the G3s freedom of action or to disperse and risk defeat in detail.