Q&A ยท 2:35:39-2:36:40

The submarine-steel question and the extra-Astute timetable

A follow-up about US submarine steel is answered separately from the proposed British construction schedule.

Question

When did the US submarine-steel quality issue become known, and how does it relate to the proposed extra British submarines?

Short answer

The 2020s is the date given, with Britain using a different steel source; this does not explain the earlier extra-Astute construction opportunities.

Notes

Recognition of the US steel problem is dated to the 2020s in this discussion, with British submarines said to obtain their steel from a different source. That timing would be too late to explain the earlier extra Astutes proposed for the counterfactual. The discussion returns to possible British starts in 2015, 2017 and 2019 and the need to leave room for Dreadnought construction. It does not establish how many American boats were affected or quantify any reduction in service life.