Q&A · 48:27-49:55

Could submarine size limits favour coastal defence?

A submarine size rule could preserve coastal boats while limiting larger designs, but the hypothetical needs a clear individual limit.

Question

Would a later naval treaty try to restrict submarine size rather than prohibit submarines?

Short answer

That approach is considered worth trying, with coastal and harbour boats accepted and the ceiling chosen carefully.

Notes

A size limit is proposed as an alternative to trying to eliminate submarines by treaty. Presenting small coastal and harbour submarines as acceptable would permit a defensive role while constraining larger boats. The exchange considers the idea feasible but does not settle a clear final ceiling. A confused numerical exchange is corrected as a range for individual boat size, rather than a cumulative allocation. Britain's T class is then mentioned as a reason to consider the effect on one's own future designs.