Q&A · 30:29-30:53

Submarine accidents and German operational risk

Germany is a likely worst case for accidental losses because submarine-heavy forces turn mishaps into severe operational and survival risks.

Question

Which navy had the worst record for accidental ship losses in World War II?

Short answer

He points to Germany, mainly because a submarine-heavy force makes accidental losses harder to absorb and more dangerous for the crew.

Notes

Force composition changes the consequences of accidents. A surface-ship accident can often be worked around, while a submarine accident quickly becomes dangerous and operationally costly. Germany's submarine-heavy wartime navy was therefore especially exposed to accident losses. The comparison explains more than a simple national ranking would.