Would Stalin take a more pragmatic position than Nicholas II in naval treaty negotiations?
Short answerYes; he could demand Anglo-American equality and settle for Japanese parity, though Japan would still reject equality with Russia.
NotesA chat comment suggests that Stalin would negotiate more pragmatically than Nicholas II. He would likely begin with a maximal demand for equality with Britain and the United States. Soviet negotiators could then present parity with Japan as a compromise rather than a defeat. Japan, however, based its security calculations on having an advantage over the Russian fleet and would resist that outcome. The bargaining tactic is plausible, but it does not remove the underlying Russo-Japanese strategic conflict.