Q&A ยท 32:56-33:14

Enemy ships set the harder requirement for naval guns

Frequent bombardment does not outweigh the need for a main battery able to survive and win a surface action.

Question

Why were naval guns not designed mainly for shore bombardment when ships fired so many rounds at land targets?

Short answer

Enemy warships imposed the more dangerous requirement because a poorly matched naval battery could get its own ship sunk.

Notes

Shore bombardment may consume a large share of a warship's ammunition, but enemy ships remain the harder design case. A gun optimized too narrowly for land targets could leave the ship unable to defeat an opponent at sea. Shore targets do not normally return fire with the same immediate ship-killing effect. The battery therefore has to meet the naval combat requirement first and perform bombardment with that capability.