Q&A · 3:45:52-3:49:24

Ships the panel would choose to serve aboard

Personal choices lead to Midway family history, Jutland battlecruiser reform, Nubian's unusually active destroyer career, and Hermes's interwar carrier and anti-piracy work.

Question

Which historical ship would the panel most like to serve aboard, and why?

Short answer

Their choices include Midway for family history, Lion to influence Jutland-era practice, Nubian for an exceptional combat career, and Hermes to witness early carrier development.

Notes

One panelist chooses USS Midway during a grandfather's service in order to meet him. Dr. Clarke considers HMS Lion before Jutland, where intervention might address dangerous battlecruiser practices, before selecting a Tribal-class destroyer such as HMS Nubian for her extraordinary operational record. Destroyer actions do not always receive battle honors under the same conventions as capital-ship engagements, helping explain why Nubian can appear less decorated than Warspite despite constant fighting. HMS Hermes in the 1920s offers another appealing choice because a sailor could watch the Royal Navy work out carrier operations and even employ an aircraft carrier on anti-piracy patrols. The answers turn a personal prompt into several distinct windows on naval service and institutional change.