Q&A · 4:34:29-4:35:50

Why allowing Germany to retain Seydlitz would widen naval arms control

Keeping a Seydlitz-scale capital ship would give Germany a much more dangerous replacement entitlement and push Britain to bring more powers into treaty limits.

Question

What changes if Britain allows Germany to retain Seydlitz after the First World War?

Short answer

Germany gains a dangerous future replacement entitlement, prompting Britain to widen and tighten the naval treaty system.

Notes

Versailles limited Germany's retained ships and controlled what could replace them. If Germany kept Seydlitz, it could later claim a replacement for a true battlecruiser rather than for an obsolete coast-defense battleship. Britain would press to include Germany and other outside powers such as Brazil and Turkey in the broader naval treaty system. An old ship's future replacement rights could matter more than its immediate fighting value.