Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:35:53-2:36:34

A carrier strike does not solve Beatty's reporting problem

Even a successful aircraft attack could worsen the trap if it slowed the Germans without improving British fleet communication.

Aircraft CarriersBattle Of JutlandCommand And ControlDavid BeattyNaval Aviation
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

What if a carrier accompanying the Battle Cruiser Fleet launched a daylight strike at Jutland?

Short answer

It might slow the Germans, but without better reporting it could leave Beatty fighting longer and make the High Seas Fleet's ambush easier rather than helping Jellicoe.

Notes

An early carrier strike would be unlikely to hit its targets. If it did slow the German battlecruisers, the resulting longer fight could make it easier for the High Seas Fleet to catch Beatty. Jellicoe would still need accurate reports to bring the Grand Fleet into action. The aircraft's success could therefore worsen the British position if Beatty failed to pass on what was happening.