Why criticize Rule the Waves' ship designer, and what does the game still simulate well?
Short answerIts generated ships can look implausible, but its fleet-management simulation covers naval development over eight decades unusually well.
NotesRule the Waves is a historical simulation rather than evidence about real ship appearance. Its generated turret layouts and carrier visuals can look implausible, while the ships' behavior remains the core of the game. Its larger value is the need to manage an entire navy from roughly 1890 to 1970 through changing technology and force structure. The visual designer may be weak even when the institutional and strategic model is strong.