Q&A · 2:58:26-2:58:54

Would HMS Edinburgh still be lost with Soviet gold?

If Barbarossa never begins, Edinburgh may have no Soviet gold mission, while safer Arctic convoy routes also reduce the risk of her historical loss.

Question

Would HMS Edinburgh still be sunk while carrying Soviet gold?

Short answer

Its fate is uncertain, but without Barbarossa it may carry no Soviet gold, and safer Arctic convoys make the historical loss less likely.

Notes

The cruiser's survival and the mission that put Soviet gold aboard are separate questions. If Germany never launches Barbarossa, Britain may not be moving Soviet gold on that route at all. Even if the eastern war still occurs, an Allied Norway makes Arctic convoys far less exposed to German attack. Edinburgh's fate remains uncertain, but both the cargo and the circumstances of its loss are likely to change.