Q&A · 38:07-39:30

Why modern patrol boats cannot replace frigates

A modern coastal combatant may add local striking power, but it does not remove the need for larger ocean-going warships.

Question

How would wartime small combatants compare with modern Royal Navy patrol boats?

Short answer

Modern patrol boats have far better sensors, but their policing and presence mission is different; armed small craft would supplement rather than replace frigates and destroyers.

Notes

Technical comparison and mission comparison lead to different answers. A modern patrol vessel benefits from much better sensors, yet it is built mainly for presence and maritime-security work rather than a gun fight with a heavily armed Dog Boat. Small, fast combatants could support operations around chokepoints and allied waters. Such vessels would remain adjuncts to frigates and destroyers rather than a reason to cut them.