Q&A · 1:35:30-1:35:44

Japan could still recall the midget-submarine attack

At this point in the counterfactual, Japanese command still has time in principle to stop the midget submarines from making their separate attack.

Question

Could Japan still stop the midget-submarine attack if Kido Butai withdrew?

Short answer

In theory, yes; there was still time to recall or halt that part of the operation.

Notes

The Pearl Harbor plan included submarine actions that could complicate a carrier recall. The midget-submarine attack could still be stopped in theory at this stage. Coordinating a cancellation across dispersed, radio-conscious forces would still take effort. A strategic decision to withdraw therefore requires subordinate operations to receive and obey the change.