Q&A · 3:03:44-3:05:12

Was Jackie Fisher a conservative revolutionary?

A hypothetical 24-knot Dreadnought with five triple 14-inch turrets illustrates how much more ambitious its design could have been.

Question

Was Fisher a conservative revolutionary?

Short answer

Yes. Dreadnought introduced major change while leaving faster machinery, larger guns, triple turrets, and superfiring arrangements unused.

Notes

Dreadnought's design left more ambitious technical options unused. In the maximal-Dreadnought alternative, stronger machinery raises speed from 21 to 24 knots and five triple 14-inch/45 gun turrets replace the historical battery. Two turrets sit forward, two aft, and one amidships. Fisher did not investigate superfiring arrangements before choosing wing turrets. Against that alternative, Dreadnought is a conservative version of the technological change it introduced.