Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 45:13-45:35

Why Captain Hill escaped punishment

Captain Hill evades the penalties imposed on Roberts's crew because profitable trade with pirates remained distinct from joining their attacks.

Maritime LawMerchant ShippingPiracyWar Profiteering
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

How was Captain Hill treated after trading with Roberts's pirates?

Short answer

He could get away with profiting from the trade so long as he did not personally cross into piracy.

Notes

A viewer asks how Captain Hill was treated after supplying Roberts and leaving Cape Lopez with valuables. Hill avoided the central offense so long as he did not personally engage in piracy. Profiting from trade with pirates could leave him morally compromised without placing him in the same legal category as a raider, especially if he otherwise paid taxes and remained part of the community. The explanation shows the gray market that sustained piracy and the narrow line contemporaries could draw between illicit commerce and violent participation.