Q&A ยท 45:58-46:16

Why did British submarines sink less merchant tonnage?

The answer warns against comparing submarine success by tonnage without accounting for target availability and different treatment of captured shipping.

Question

Why did British submarines sink less German shipping than German U-boats sank Allied shipping in World War I?

Short answer

British boats had far fewer German targets at sea and often captured merchant ships instead of sinking them.

Notes

British submarines faced a much smaller pool of German merchant targets because so much enemy shipping remained in harbor. When a suitable vessel was found, British forces also had reason to capture it and examine or reuse the cargo rather than destroy it. German U-boats operated against a far larger stream of Allied commerce and therefore accumulated more sinking tonnage. Geography, target supply, and operational practice make the raw totals a poor measure of submarine quality.