Q&A · 2:12:46-2:14:01

Flawed warship programs that might have worked

The panel identifies carrier rebuilds and modular combatants whose underlying ideas could have succeeded with different sequencing, lower speed, or better execution.

Question

Which apparently bad warship design or program might actually have become successful?

Short answer

Victorious's rebuild, an Implacable-first carrier modernization, a slower second-block LCS, and a properly implemented StanFlex system all had plausible routes to success.

Notes

HMS Victorious's reconstruction is offered as a concept that might have looked much better without the later fire and its consequences. Rebuilding the newer Implacable-class carriers first could also have placed scarce modernization effort into hulls with more remaining life. A second-block Littoral Combat Ship might have become useful if the United States accepted less speed and designed the follow-on around practical endurance and payload. Properly implementing the Danish StanFlex modular system is the final example, emphasizing that a sound idea can fail when copied without the institutions and discipline that made it work.