Q&A · 33:54-34:10

Fishing boats as Pearl Harbor warning pickets

Japanese use of fishing boats as offshore observers prompts a question about whether Admiral Kimmel could have funded a similar warning screen before Pearl Harbor.

Question

Could Admiral Kimmel have used fishing boats as offshore pickets before Pearl Harbor?

Short answer

Yes, but the Navy would first have needed political funding for a warning measure it had already considered.

Notes

The United States could have used civilian fishing boats as pickets before the attack on Pearl Harbor. The idea was within American planning and technical ability. The obstacle was obtaining money from politicians for a precaution whose value would become clearest only after an attack. Inexpensive layers of early warning are difficult to fund before a crisis proves their need.