Q&A · 1:09:10-1:10:24

Can a country without a navy win a naval war?

The premise is historically difficult because successful challengers normally build or acquire naval power.

Question

Has a country with no navy ever won a naval war against a country that had one?

Short answer

Not in a clean example. States such as Rome built naval power, and the American case depended on allied fleets.

Notes

The answer depends on what counts as a country without a navy. Rome built a fleet before defeating Carthage at sea, so it does not satisfy the premise. American independence depended substantially on French and Spanish naval intervention. No clear case of a state with no naval power defeating an opponent in a naval war is identified here.