Q&A · 3:13:09-3:13:31

Montgomery and concern for casualties

A corrective answer rejects the idea that Montgomery regarded Canadian or other troops as expendable cannon fodder.

Question

Did Montgomery treat Canadian troops as cannon fodder?

Short answer

No; he cared deeply about his troops and was visibly affected by their losses.

Notes

The answer firmly rejects the claim that Montgomery viewed Canadian troops as cannon fodder. Montgomery is described as emotionally affected by the soldiers he lost and attentive to them as individuals. This does not settle every criticism of his operations, but it separates tactical debate from an unsupported claim of indifference. The exchange adds a human dimension to the earlier comparison between Montgomery and Slim.