Q&A ยท 2:20:56-2:21:38

How long were mixed cruiser batteries defensible?

Fire-control limits and inherited doctrine explain some delay after 1905, but not indefinite resistance to unified heavy batteries.

Question

Could mixed main batteries remain justifiable after 1905 because of fire-control limits?

Short answer

Briefly; fire control, inherited doctrine, and foreign practice explain some lag, but they do not justify indefinite delay once unified batteries were workable.

Notes

Contemporary fire control still complicated long-range shooting, which could justify allowing designers until about 1908 to abandon mixed batteries. Technical limits, inherited doctrine, and the fact that other navies continued building them explain some persistence. That allowance was temporary rather than absolute. Once a navy could build a unified heavy battery, continuing with multiple calibres sacrificed fire control and logistics without a compelling operational return.