Who wins between a Lexington-class and an Amagi-class battlecruiser?
Short answerLexington has the edge if it controls the battle's pace and range; Amagi is favored if it can close.
NotesArmour and gun tables alone do not produce a universal winner. Lexington needs to use speed and range to decide when and how the action occurs. Amagi becomes more dangerous if it closes and turns the encounter into the fight it prefers. Tactical initiative and control of distance determine how design strengths translate into combat results.