Q&A · 1:55:38-1:57:02

The case for the King George V class's 14-inch guns

Ten modern 14-inch guns and strong armor remained effective even when rival ships carried larger calibers.

Question

What use were the King George V-class battleships if their opponents carried larger guns?

Short answer

Their modern 14-inch battery, high gun count, and armor remained formidable at expected combat ranges, even though the treaty compromise aged badly.

Notes

The British were designing for realistic engagement ranges, where a modern 14-inch shell could still defeat important targets. Ten guns offered a heavy salvo, and the original twelve-gun ambition illustrates the attraction of volume over a smaller number of 15-inch weapons. The class also carried strong protection, so gun caliber cannot be judged apart from rate of fire, accuracy, and survivability. The political purpose of choosing 14 inches was to sustain a treaty limit, but Japan's withdrawal and the American escalator clause undermined that bargain after construction was too advanced to reverse.