Q&A · 3:39:54-3:40:39

Why Incomparable falls short of the fast-battleship label

Contemporary fleet speed, not simply being faster than older battleships, controls the fast-battleship label.

Question

Would HMS Incomparable qualify as an early fast battleship?

Short answer

Not under the period standard used here, because her projected 27 knots remained below the roughly 28-knot cruiser speed used to define a fast battleship.

Notes

Incomparable could be advertised as an unusually fast battleship, but her projected 27 knots would miss the operational threshold used by major navies. In this framework a fast battleship had to keep pace with contemporary cruisers, which placed the dividing line around 28 knots or more.