Q&A ยท 2:38:58-2:39:37

Hoche and the problems of successive redesigns

Hoche's changing requirements and succession of designers offer a distinct explanation for an awkward design.

Question

Which ship suffered the worst design by committee?

Short answer

German light cruisers are one suggestion; Hoche suffered repeated redesigns by successive designers as battleship requirements changed.

Notes

German light cruisers receive an initial nomination for the worst design by committee. Hoche's problems arose through successive redesigns during a prolonged construction period. As ideas about battleships changed, the ship's design changed again. Responsibility also passed between designers, each with a different idea of what the ship should become.