Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 44:14-44:49

Graf Spee against a full-strength County and Town

A River Plate counterfactual replaces Exeter's actual force with a full-strength County-class cruiser and a Town-class partner, producing a much worse prospect for Admiral Graf Spee.

Admiral Graf SpeeBattle Of The River PlateCounty Class CruisersHMS ExeterTown Class Light Cruisers (1936)
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

How would Admiral Graf Spee fare against a full-strength County-class cruiser and a Town-class cruiser?

Short answer

Badly. A full-strength County and Town pairing would make the engagement very dangerous for the German ship.

Notes

The viewer frames the question around Exeter's luck at the Battle of the River Plate, including German shells that passed through without detonating. The proposed alternative gives Admiral Graf Spee a full-strength County-class cruiser and a Town-class cruiser as opponents. Such a pairing would have been very bad for the German ship. That judgment rests on the force's composition and the damage effects described by the viewer, rather than nominal gun calibre alone.