Q&A · 3:27:46-3:30:48

A World of Warships design replaces Bismarck and Tirpitz

A pair of alternative battleships changes little, but standardizing on the smaller design across several German programs could create a far larger force.

Question

How much worse off would Germany be with two World of Warships designs armed with nine 350 mm guns instead of Bismarck and Tirpitz?

Short answer

A pair alone changes little, but using the design as a standardized replacement across several classes could give Germany a much more numerous and dangerous surface fleet.

Notes

The World of Warships design carries nine 350 mm guns, described here as First World War weapons. Initial assessments differ: replacing only Bismarck and Tirpitz could leave Germany little better off or produce a weaker pair of capital ships. The possibilities change if the same design also replaces the Hipper and Scharnhorst programs. Concentrating construction on one type could yield a much larger force, with speculative estimates ranging from six ships to about twelve and perhaps capacity to finish Graf Zeppelin. A numerous fleet would give Britain more ships to track and contain. Those rough production estimates depend on the assumed savings from standardization.