Q&A ยท 3:18:33-3:19:09

Force Z facing the Nagato class

Prince of Wales and Repulse would use their speed to disengage rather than fight two Japanese 16-inch battleships.

Question

What if Force Z met the Nagato sisters instead of Japanese aircraft?

Short answer

Force Z would withdraw at high speed, perhaps exchanging fire, because it could not profitably fight two 16-inch battleships.

Notes

Prince of Wales could not sensibly fight both Nagato-class battleships alone. Repulse's battlecruiser protection makes a sustained action against their 16-inch guns unattractive. Both British ships have the speed to get away. An exchange of gunfire is possible during withdrawal, but the objective would be to disengage as quickly as possible.