Notable Point · 28:57-31:17

How fleet exercises underestimated attacks on destroyers

Interwar pilots repeatedly chose prestigious capital-ship and carrier targets in exercises, encouraging several navies to understate the air threat to destroyers.

Notes

Royal Navy Tribal-class destroyers entered service with low-angle 4.7-inch main guns partly because exercise experience suggested aircraft would bypass small ships for carriers and capital ships. That pattern was a false positive created by the incentives of peacetime training. A pilot risked no life by pressing toward the largest target and gained more prestige from a simulated carrier hit than from attacking a destroyer. British, American, and other navies then treated this behavior as evidence about wartime targeting. Combat exposed the cost of designing destroyer air defence around an opponent who was not making peacetime choices.