Q&A ยท 2:23:07-2:25:01

Favourite World War II carriers and why stories matter

Enterprise, Ark Royal, Illustrious, and Indefatigable stand out here for their distinctive service stories rather than a single technical ranking.

Question

Which World War II carriers stand out as favourites?

Short answer

USS Enterprise, HMS Ark Royal, HMS Illustrious, and HMS Indefatigable stand out chiefly for their histories and service stories.

Notes

Favourite ships need not form a technical ranking of the best class. USS Enterprise, HMS Ark Royal, HMS Illustrious, and HMS Indefatigable make up a shifting top group, depending on which service story is most compelling at the time. Unicorn receives an honorary place because her forward aviation-support role does not fit neatly into the carrier category, and some escort carriers also have compelling histories. A favourite-ship list can reward operational experience and narrative distinctiveness without pretending to rank designs.