Q&A ยท 3:36:22-3:36:48

Reviewing a book by someone you know

A reviewer may assess an acquaintance's book if the relationship is disclosed and the criticism is candid enough to say face to face.

Question

Is it professionally ethical to review a book when you know the author?

Short answer

Yes, provided the relationship is disclosed and the reviewer remains candid, fair, and willing to make the same criticism face to face.

Notes

A reviewer can assess a book by someone they know if the relationship is stated openly so readers can judge the connection. Acquaintance is no reason to hide errors or soften substantive criticism. A useful practical rule is never to publish something about an author's work that you would not be willing to say directly to that person.