Q&A · 3:04:24-3:04:52

Why equal-cost fleet comparisons can mislead

Equal game budgets obscure differences in British and Japanese construction costs, resources and available fleets.

Question

Can the combat be balanced by giving both sides the same cost?

Short answer

It can be done as a game experiment, but it is historically misleading because British and Japanese resources, construction costs, and available ship numbers were not equivalent.

Notes

The game's common cost calculation gives equal spending a misleading historical appearance. British ship construction is judged cheaper than Japanese construction because the countries have different resources. Their available ship numbers also differ. An equal-cost battle can be attempted as a game experiment, but it does not reproduce those national advantages and constraints.