Q&A · 1:28:03-1:32:53

Why smaller Deutschland guns would not prevent Dunkerque

Replacing Deutschland's 11-inch battery with more 8.3-inch guns changes the armament but not the raider mission or France's incentive to resume capital-ship construction.

Question

How would France and Italy respond to a Deutschland class armed with 8.3-inch guns?

Short answer

Italy could rely on its heavy cruisers, while France would still build Dunkerque and Strasbourg for broader strategic reasons.

Notes

Italy already possessed heavy cruisers capable of handling a Deutschland armed with 8.3-inch guns, so it would not need a special reply. France would still use new German construction to justify Dunkerque and Strasbourg, which also answered wider Mediterranean requirements and Italian heavy cruisers. A battery of more 210 mm weapons would alter the German ship's firepower without changing its basic commerce-raiding purpose. France's deeper problem was difficulty turning available technology and arms spending into coherent joint doctrine and implementation.