Q&A ยท 4:37-5:12

Why the Courageous class did not improve on Renown

The shallow-draft claim did not compensate for the Courageous class's failure to improve materially on the Renown design.

Question

In what ways was the Courageous class supposed to improve on Renown?

Short answer

Apart from a claimed shallow-water capability, the Courageous design offered no meaningful improvement over the Renowns.

Notes

The premise that the Courageous class materially improved on Renown is rejected. Its claimed ability to work in shallow water is treated as the only plausible advantage. Even that appears more like a justification for the design than a decisive operational gain. In fighting value and overall balance, Courageous and her sisters offered no improvement over the Renowns.