Phoebe came close enough for Essex's 32-pounder carronades to inflict serious damage and mortally wound her first lieutenant. American fire also damaged sails and rigging in an effort to limit Phoebe's speed. Hillyar increased the distance and used the respite to repair the rig and furl the damaged mainsail. He ordered Cherub to remain underway so she could maneuver and maintain separation. When the British resumed at roughly half a mile, their 18-pounders remained effective while most American carronade shot struck the water or rocks.
Notable Point · 1:56:19-1:58:50
Essex's carronades punished one mistake before Hillyar reset the fight
Phoebe briefly entered effective carronade range, suffered serious casualties and rigging damage, then withdrew to repair and resumed the engagement from about half a mile.