Which Second World War aircraft carriers would be most interesting in a surface gunfight?
Short answerThe early Lexingtons had the heaviest cruiser-style guns, but an armoured British carrier or HMS Unicorn would be difficult and historically revealing opponents.
NotesLexington and Saratoga are the first candidates while they retained their eight-inch batteries. British armoured carriers bring greater protection to the contest. HMS Unicorn provides the clearest operational example because she used her four-inch guns for shore bombardment during the Korean War. The comparison turns on both cruiser-style armament and the ability to survive a close action.