Q&A · 24:08-25:35

Which aircraft carriers were equipped for a surface gunfight?

Lexington and Saratoga brought eight-inch guns, while armoured British carriers and HMS Unicorn offer different combinations of protection and willingness to engage shore targets.

Question

Which Second World War aircraft carriers would be most interesting in a surface gunfight?

Short answer

The early Lexingtons had the heaviest cruiser-style guns, but an armoured British carrier or HMS Unicorn would be difficult and historically revealing opponents.

Notes

Lexington and Saratoga are the first candidates while they retained their eight-inch batteries. British armoured carriers bring greater protection to the contest. HMS Unicorn provides the clearest operational example because she used her four-inch guns for shore bombardment during the Korean War. The comparison turns on both cruiser-style armament and the ability to survive a close action.