Q&A ยท 3:14:40-3:15:52

Could Fisher have softened Dreadnought's disruptive effect?

An immediate order for eight dreadnoughts could preserve Britain's lead even though the new type reduced the relative value of its older ships.

Question

How could Admiral Fisher have introduced Dreadnought without weakening Britain's relative battleship advantage?

Short answer

He could not avoid obsolescence, but ordering a large first batch would preserve a daunting numerical lead.

Notes

Introducing Dreadnought inevitably changes the relative value of the pre-dreadnought fleet. The proposed way to cushion Britain's position is to order eight of the new ships immediately. That would establish an eight-to-none lead while competitors began their programs. If Germany then ordered four and Britain ordered another four, the hypothetical totals would become twelve against four. This preserves a numerical advantage in the new type without reversing the effect on older battleships.