Q&A ยท 2:12:40-2:13:02

An explosive freighter attack on Pearl Harbor

The freighter counterfactual separates possible physical damage from a US expectation of war with Japan.

Question

Would a Halifax-style explosive freighter attack at Pearl Harbor intensify the US response?

Short answer

It would not fundamentally change US determination to fight Japan, though a successful harbor explosion might damage the fleet more severely than the historical raid.

Notes

Alex answers no to the proposed change in the American response. He nevertheless suggests that an explosive freighter, if successful, could cause more damage to the fleet in harbor than the actual attack did. He immediately adds that the United States had already expected war with Japan. The proposed damage remains unquantified and conditional on the attack succeeding.