Q&A · 46:29-47:44

Eighteen-inch battleships and twelve-inch cruisers

A treaty-era design answer imagines 18-inch battleships making 12-inch-gun large cruisers a more viable category.

Question

If 18-inch guns become the upper limit, do battlecruisers or large cruisers appear before the Second World War?

Short answer

The category could shift toward 12-inch-gun large cruisers, with treaty definitions and the retention of older battlecruisers changing around the larger battleship standard.

Notes

Ship categories depend on the standards around them. If 18-inch guns become the battleship norm, a 12-inch armed ship becomes a more plausible large cruiser instead of an obvious capital ship. The Washington Treaty might then define a separate large-cruiser category. Britain might also retain older 12-inch battlecruisers longer or reduce the armament of 13.5-inch ships while replacements are built.